During her time with World Championship Wrestling (WCW), Keibler was romantically linked to David Flair, the son of wrestler Ric Flair.
When she was actively involved with the WWE, Keibler dated wrestler Andrew “Test” Martin both on and off screen.
After re-locating to L.A. in 2004, Keibler entered a relationship with actor Geoff Stults, who is best known for his minor role in the TV series 7th Heaven.
After splitting with Stults in 2010, Keibler began dating George Clooney a year later and stayed with the older older until July of 2013.
Keibler is now with Future Ads CEO Jared Pobre, who is making her forget about the split with Clooney.