Does Carlos Ruiz Deserve to Start for the National League in the All-Star Game?
Carlos Ruiz has always been an underrated catcher both offensively and defensively, but he’s taken his game to a whole new level in 2012.
Ruiz has been the most consistent player on the Philadelphia Phillies, and he’s hitting at a .371 clip with an incredible .609 slugging percentage. Ruiz has nearly as many home runs (8) as he hit all of last year, and he’s leading the league with a perfect 1.000 fielding percentage behind the date. He’s also handling a starting pitching staff that rates fourth in WAR (5.9) and leads the major leagues in xFIP (3.27).
The National League has a handful of catchers playing at a high level in 2012. Here are Ruiz’s top competitors for the starting spot in the All-Star Game.
Brian McCann is a perennial NL All-Star, having made six, so I included him but it’s obvious that this just isn’t his best year. Miguel Montero was just rewarded with a five-year contract extension (worth $60 million!), and he’s a fine catcher, but not deserving of the All-Star team. And Buster Posey has a slew of credentials already – Rookie of the Year and a World Series ring plus a .300 season at age 23, but he’s a little overmatched compared to the others on this list.
And Jonathan Lucroy – who is right in the mix for starting catcher – just broke his hand and will be out at least a month, so I think that makes it safe to remove him from the list.
That leaves three catchers competing for the starting spot on the All-Star team: Ruiz, A.J. Ellis, and Yadier Molina. Molina and Ruiz have the enormous edge on Ellis for the name factor, as Ellis is a relative unknown enjoying a truly remarkable season for a first place team.
Looking at the numbers, Ruiz leads in batting average, on-base percentage, slugging percentage, and OPS, which has in turn given him 2.8 wins above that of a replacement player, the highest total of any catcher in the game this season.
Defensively, Molina is renowned for his cannon of a throwing arm, which has helped him throw out 38.5 percent of would-be base stealers this season. But Ruiz isn’t too shabby himself, as he’s at 36.8 percent, and Ruiz has made fewer errors (2-1) which leads to a higher fielding percentage (.997-.994).
Ruiz has had a terrific career, but he’s never made an All-Star team. He’s helped the Phillies win a World Series and five consecutive NL East titles, he’s batted higher than .300 in six of 10 postseason series, and he’s caught both a no-hitter and a perfect game. He’s even stepped into the lineup as the cleanup hitter, with Ryan Howard rehabbing from a torn Achilles injury and Hunter Pence struggling in the role.
And soon, Ruiz can expect to have an All-Star added onto his resume.
5 Reasons Why Brewers Should Bring Back Mark Reynolds
Mark Reynolds struggled for much of last season, but here are five reasons why the Brewers should bring him back for 2015. Read More