David Ortiz Is Not Yet A Hall Of Famer And It Has Nothing To Do With Stats

Greg M.Cooper-USA TODAY Sports

David Ortiz, designated hitter of the Boston Red Sox, had another personal milestone against the Detroit Tigers on Wednesday night when he got his 2,000 Major League hit of his career. He is a nine-time All-Star and is one of 51 players who have at least 400 career home runs. He has the Red Sox single-season record of most home runs in the regular season with 54. If you are a Red Sox fan, you cannot forget his heroics in 2004 against the New York Yankees. He has won an MVP and is a five-time winner of the Silver Slugger Award. All in all, he has maintained almost a decade of excellence. Those are statistics that should almost be a lock for getting into the Hall of Fame when he is done or at least, serious consideration. However, he may not even get close and it has nothing to do with his numbers.

Ortiz may not see the Hall of Fame anytime soon after he retires and it is all because of the position he plays … or the lack of one in the voter’s eyes. He is a designated hitter and arguably one of the best of all time and that is what could keep him from getting into Cooperstown. Here’s why. The litmus test of whether or not Ortiz could get into the Hall someday was Edgar Martinez. Martinez probably was the greatest designated hitter ever and so far is the only DH to win a batting title. He first showed up on the ballot in 2010 and only received 36.2% of the vote, not remotely close for election. Each year since then, his support has not really increased. The highest it has ever been is 36.5% in 2012. If Martinez, really the first pure designated hitter can’t get in, what does it mean for Ortiz? Many voters do not consider the DH a true position and because of that, Martinez and Ortiz could be on the outside looking in for a long time.

Voters seem to not grasp that the game is changing and their voting should change with it. It has only been very recently that you started seeing closers elected in the Hall on a regular basis and there are many great closers who aren’t and probably won’t get elected. Unfortunately, the same may hold true for Big Papi. Ironically, Ortiz probably could play a position in the field if he needed to. He has played some first base in interleague and World Series games. While he is no Keith Hernandez, he has held his own out there.

I don’t think there is any doubt that Boston will retire his number when he is done. I don’t think there is any question that he will be considered the greatest designated hitter ever. Getting into Cooperstown will probably be a different story. Too bad Ortiz’s speech could be one for the ages.

Carter Roane is a Boston Red Sox writer for Rant Sports. Follow him on Twitter @CarterGRoane, “Like” him on Facebook or add him to your network on Google.


Boston Red Sox’ David Ortiz Just Adding to His Hall-of-Fame Resume

David Ortiz Continues to Make Case for Hall of Fame With 2,000-Hit Resume

Boston Red Sox Send Detroit Tigers A Message

Around the Web

  • Dave

    Wow, this is a really short-sighted article. Edgar was a great hitter with some power (only 309 HR’s). Papi has 427 and isn’t done yet. He’ll have 500 by retirement, plus minimum 2 World Series titles plus heroics. Edgar didn’t do any of that. Edgar was very good for his career; Ortiz has been one of the most feared hitters in the game for a decade (and he’s not done yet). Top-5 in MVP voting 5 times for Papi, once for Edgar. Ortiz is one level higher than Edgar ever was, and that’s why he will be the first DH to make it to Cooperstown. Bet on it.

    • Carter Roane

      Hey Dave,
      Thanks for reading my article. I appreciate it very much! I do think the way these voters are at selecting players into the Hall of Fame, it is going to very difficult for Ortiz to get in. If he puts up some huge offensive numbers, maybe that will be enough so voters can’t ignore his statistics but a lot of these voters are notoriously fickle for who they select. Like I mentioned in my article, they have just recently started electing closers. I can just see them not wanting to elect a DH because they don’t play the field. I hope I am wrong, would love to see Papi in there.

  • Ole Man

    The point about the DH is well taken.
    But for yet another reason, David doesn’t belong.
    He was a juicer. And he wouldn’t have accomplished nearly as much without the juice.

    • Carter Roane

      Thank you for reading! There really is no solid evidence that Ortiz has ever juiced. However, you bring up a good point. Voters seem to not vote for any player that not only have never been tested positive but don’t have any solid proof, just the suspicion that maybe they could have. Jeff Bagwell is a player like that. Even these very vague rumors could keep Ortiz out.

      • Ole Man

        Carter, he was named as a juicer. Do you have to be there and watch him shooting up?

        • GMP75

          @Ole Man get your facts straight. First off he was never suspended for any type of PED use. In fact there is no evidence that he did test positive for any steroids. The New York Times off all news papers (kind of find that fishy dont you?) reported in 2009 that he tested positive for PEDs
          during the 2003 season. Ortiz later said a combination of then-legal
          supplements and vitamins likely caused a positive test.