X

Have feedback / suggestions? Let us know!

MLB New York Yankees

MLB All-Star Game: 5 Reasons Why Dellin Betances Doesn’t Belong

Dellin Betances Shouldn't Be An All-Star

Dellin Betances New York Yankees
Getty Images

New York Yankees relief pitcher Dellin Betances made the All-Star team in his first full season. He is finally living up to his potential when he was one of the team's Killer B's in the minor leagues. He only posted eight games prior to this season, now, he already has appeared in 37 games. He has posted a 1.55 ERA and a 0.75 WHIP in a bullpen that has saved the Yankees this season. With all that said, he still doesn't deserve to be an All-Star.

5) He's Never Played On This Big of a Stage

1) He Never Played On This Big A Stage
Getty Images

5) He's Never Played On This Big of a Stage

1) He Never Played On This Big A Stage
Getty Images

As a set-up man, Betances hasn't had a ton of pressure on him this season. He doesn't close very often (in fact, he got his first save on Monday night). Of course, one could argue that there is pressure in the eighth, but not nearly as much as an inning later. There are millions of eyes staring at you during the All-Star game. Can he deal with that kind of pressure when the game actually counts?

4) Seven American League Relief Pitchers Have Better ERAs

2) Seven American League Relief Pitchers Have Better ERAs
Getty Images

4) Seven American League Relief Pitchers Have Better ERAs

2) Seven American League Relief Pitchers Have Better ERAs
Getty Images

One of the reasons that you want Betances on your All-Star team is his sparkling ERA. Even with that said, there are seven relief pitchers who best him in that category. Not one of those players made the team. While it isn't a crime that they chose Betances over the likes of Zach Britton or Wade Davis, it seems there may be some New York bias here.

3) David Robertson Might Be More Deserving

3) David Robertson Might Be More Deserving
Getty Images

3) David Robertson Might Be More Deserving

3) David Robertson Might Be More Deserving
Getty Images

While David Robertson doesn't have the eye-popping numbers that Betances has, he has had to deal with much harder circumstances. For one, he is the closer. He has had to deal with the media from day one. Besides that, if you take out one bad outing (5 ER in .2 IP), he would have a lower ERA than Betances (1.50 against 1.55). Oh, and there is that little situation of having to replace the greatest closer of all-time in Mariano Rivera.

2) There Are A Ton Of Great Eighth Inning Pitchers

4) There Are A Ton Of Great Eighth Inning Pitchers
Getty Images

2) There Are A Ton Of Great Eighth Inning Pitchers

4) There Are A Ton Of Great Eighth Inning Pitchers
Getty Images

When you look around the American League, half of the teams have very good eighth inning pitchers. Heck, Darren O'Day of the Baltimore Orioles and Jake McGee of the Tampa Bay Rays have both had better statistical seasons than Betances. It seems like a position that is easier to excel at.

1) He Has Been Somewhat Lucky

5) He Has Been Somewhat Lucky
Getty Images

1) He Has Been Somewhat Lucky

5) He Has Been Somewhat Lucky
Getty Images

I don't want to discount what Betances has done this season by saying it has all been luck, but when hitters have a .220 average on balls in play, then you have to worry about regression. Only ten pitchers have a lower BABIP against them. This definitely has something to do with his great stuff, but it also has to do with the ball going to the right spot.