By John Shea @real_johnshea on August 9, 2014
The Miami Marlins are on the verge of "achieving" yet another massive organizational blunder. According to Jon Heyman of CBS Sports, the Marlins intend to re-sign slugging outfielder Giancarlo Stanton to a long-term extension this offseason. On the surface, re-upping Stanton for the foreseeable future appears like a no-brainer, but the instability of the Marlins as an organization make long-term guarantees detrimental to potential future success.
The objective in retaining Stanton is to theoretically build around him in attempt to construct a World Series-caliber team. That's not exactly the Marlins' motive for dishing out a well-deserved extension to one of the best power hitters in the game, though. Miami ranks 27th in home attendance this season, averaging less than 22,000 fans per game. Stanton is a big reason for ticket sales, but fans want a winner. Take the Miami Heat, for example.
The Marlins lack the structure necessary to consistently put forth a high-quality on the field product. Re-signing Stanton would merely perpetuate the status of a defunct organization, given the return the club could net for a player of his caliber. The Marlins haven't had a winning season since 2009, despite frivolous spending prior to the 2012 campaign, which saw the fish win just 69 games. Retaining Stanton won't change Miami's losing trend.
Stanton's trade value is currently at its peak. The 24-year-old slugger is under club control through the 2016 season, which would give a trade suitor a minimum of two years to negotiate a long-term deal, and potentially buy out his remaining two seasons of arbitration. Stanton owns a whopping .939 OPS this season. He leads the NL in home runs (28), RBI (77) and walks (68), yet the Marlins are three games below the .500 mark.
According to Baseball Prospectus, the Marlins boast the 19th "best" farm system in the big leagues, a reality of which is detrimental to the franchise's future, given their inability to sustain long-term spending. Trading Stanton would enable the Marlins to acquire at least three, if not more, highly touted prospects who flaunt serious major-league potential. At the moment, Miami doesn't have much to look forward to in the minor league ranks.
The Marlins aren't typically in the business of handing down gigantic contracts to type-A players, excluding the anomaly otherwise known as 2012. While the club's brain trust might be optimistic, given the hopeful return of staff ace Jose Fernandez in 2015, the Marlins don't have enough perennial talent to consistently contend in the ultra-competitive NL East even with Stanton in uniform. Trading Stanton this offseason is the right move.
December 21, 2014 by Pete Schwichtenberg
The Philadelphia Phillies are not going to contend this season. With that in mind, here is why finding a trade partner for Ryan Howard would be the perfect Christmas gift for the club. Read More
December 21, 2014 by Pablo Jacobo
Former Cy Young winner Max Scherzer would bolster the emerging pitching staff of the Los Angeles Angels. He may be the missing piece for a title run. Read More
December 21, 2014 by Justin Broyles
The Baltimore Orioles have a hole in their outfield, but they should not turn to Delmon Young to fill it. Read More
December 21, 2014 by Ben Linton
The rotation of the Baltimore Orioles were third in the AL with a 3.44 ERA last season. Here is a prediction of what their rotation will look like after the 2014 Winter Meetings. Read More
The Los Angeles Dodgers could have the best starting rotation in baseball if they acquire Cole Hamels. Can management strike another deal with Philadelphia? Read More
December 21, 2014 by Brandon Williams
In a season that ended in turmoil, the one constant was the Braves' starting rotation. They finished with one of the best ERAs in baseball. Check out the prediction for 2015's starting rotation. Read More
December 21, 2014 by Bryan Zarpentine
The New York Mets shouldn't trade for Troy Tulowitzki unless Colorado's price for him comes down. What exactly does that mean? Find out here. Read More
December 21, 2014 by Owen Gabbey
The New York Yankees have a major gap to fill at second base. A quality, young second baseman would be a great addition for them this Christmas. Read More
December 20, 2014 by Alex Drude
The numbers say Casey McGehee isn't that different from Pablo Sandoval. But numbers aren't everything. Read More
December 20, 2014 by Max Zelenko
Who will be in the Boston Red Sox starting rotation in 2015 after the Winter Meetings? Find out here. Read More
December 20, 2014 by Drew Jenkins
The San Diego Padres have filled some huge holes on their team in recent days, but a new shortstop is still on top of their holiday wishlist. Read More
December 20, 2014 by Matt Turner
Whether its at shortstop or in the outfield, the New York Mets need to add one more player for them to become real threats. Read More