Two years ago, Pedro Alvarez was one of the brightest stars on the Pittsburgh Pirates‘ roster. After years of being a streaky player, it looked as if Alvarez had finally figured it out in 2013, tying Paul Goldschmidt for the NL home run title and knocking in 100 runs. But this season, Alvarez relapsed and returned to the streaky player he had been in the past. And for that reason, it is the prime time to trade Alvarez.
Even if Alvarez had another good season in Pittsburgh, he probably would have been traded this offseason anyway. Alvarez only has one more year of arbitration, and that means he will be in for a big raise coming off of a bad season. It also means that Alvarez will probably leave next year anyway. With the Pirates needing to find more money in order to bring back catcher Russell Martin, dumping Alvarez on another team seems like a good way to free up salary. But this only works if the Pirates have a replacement for Alvarez.
Luckily, Pittsburgh does have a replacement on their squad. The emergence of Josh Harrison at third base has made Alvarez expendable. Harrison was a spark plug for the Pirates the entire season and provided much more value than Alvarez. Harrison is also liked much more in Pittsburgh, so the move would most likely be embraced by the fanbase.
The most important reason that Alvarez needs to go is his play on the field. He has historically been a steady glove at third base, but this season he could not throw a ball from third to first to record an out. And at the plate, Alvarez showed little of his power, often racking up strikeouts unless he was thrown fastballs right down the middle. This is something that the Pirates do not need in their lineup if they plan on contending year after year.
Alvarez was a great power threat for the Pirates the last few years, but now it seems like he has hit a wall and needs a change of scenery. He seems to be a good fit as a DH in the AL, and teams like the Boston Red Sox have shown interest in him. With that interest out there, combined with the bad play, big salary and replacement ready to take over, it seems like the perfect storm to trade Alvarez. He had some good times in Pittsburgh, but it is in both parties’ best interest to move on this offseason.
Justin Broyles is a Pirates writer for www.RantSports.com. Follow him on twitter @Tweets_ByJ, “Like” him on Facebook or add him to your network on Google.
The Oakland Athletics continue to make a splash in the offseason by trading for Ben Zobrist and Yunel Escobar from the Tampa Bay Rays. Read More
The Atlanta Braves have a lot more moves to make before the start of the season. Take a look at these players the Braves should consider trading for. Read More
With multiple uncertainties in the starting rotation, it would be huge if the Detroit Tigers could get a breakout season out of newcomer Shane Greene. Read More
With the Tampa Bay Rays heading into a transitional season, here are five players they should still look to trade. Read More
The San Francisco Giants aren't as dangerous on paper as they were a season ago. Read More
It has been a long time since John Axford has been great. With a need for bullpen help, the Toronto Blue Jays should take a chance on him. Read More
The St. Louis Cardinals are reportedly interested in adding an ace, and signing James Shields would be the best way for them to do so. Read More
The NL Central boasts the best catchers in all of baseball. Here is how they rank heading into the 2015 season. Read More
Here is why Detroit Tigers catcher Alex Avila may benefit immensely from a strict platoon with James McCann in 2015. Read More
The Kansas City Royals made significant moves at the end of 2014, but the Chicago White Sox changed their team in a much bigger way. The Royals will now see far more of two well-liked former players. Read More
Will he be a Seattle Mariner or an Arizona Diamondback in the Hall of Fame? Either way, Randy Johnson's legacy will be remembered in Seattle long before it is forgotten. Read More
The Cincinnati Reds have lost a lot of organizational depth this winter. By adding Keyvius Sampson, they have a pitcher who has the talent to quickly surprise. Read More