St. Louis Cardinals Should Pursue Free Agent Catcher Nick Hundley
One of the St. Louis Cardinals‘ worst nightmares came to life in 2014 when star catcher Yadier Molina went down with an injury both during the regular season and the playoffs. Losing Molina was bad enough; after all he has been one of, if not the best catcher in baseball for the past few years, and he has been an All-Star each of the last six seasons.
Compounding his loss, however, was the fact that the Cardinals’ backup catcher was Tony Cruz, who has been a below replacement level player in his career, as his minus-0.4 career fWAR indicates. This was poor planning by the Cardinals, and it came back to haunt them. Thus, the Cardinals need to add insurance at catcher this offseason, and adding free agent Nick Hundley is a way they could do that.
Hundley is nothing spectacular, but he would be an upgrade over Cruz and passable as a starter if Molina were to get hurt again. Over his career, Hundley has hit .238/.294/.386 with an 88 wRC+, a significant improvement over Cruz’s .225/.271/.310 line and 59 wRC+. Hundley’s 75 wRC+ in 2014 was also significantly better than Cruz’s 51 mark. The Cardinals were tied for just 23rd in runs scored in 2014, and while Hundley would not be the savior of the offense, every little bit helps.
Defensively, Hundley has a slight edge over Cruz. His 27 percent career caught stealing rate is worse than Cruz’s 31 percent career rate, but overall, Hundley is the better catcher. Over the past three years, Hundley has been worth 8.9, 12.5 and 3.2 respective runs above-average on defense according to Fangraph’s Def stat whereas Cruz has been worth 2.5, 1.9 and 0.5. Hundley is no pitch-framing wizard, but in 2014 he was worth 1.9 runs above-average whereas Cruz was 7.4 runs below average.
Hundley also brings more experience than Cruz, which is an underrated intangible for catchers. Over his big league career, Hundley has appeared in 516 games at catcher while Cruz has seen just 158 games of action. That is a significant difference, and as a former starter, Hundley has more experience in handling a big league pitching staff than Cruz.
Hundley would also not be a significant cost for the Cardinals. Last season he made $4 million, but after the Baltimore Orioles declined his $5 million team option for 2015, he seems likely likely make less than the $4 million mark. Given the value of catchers, he might be in line for a short multi-year deal if he so chooses. Something along the lines of a one-year, $2.5 million or a two-year, $4.5 million deal seems reasonable. Cruz is still under control as a pre-arbitration player, meaning his 2015 salary would be in the ballpark of $500,000. Still, the approximately $2 million difference in Hundley and Cruz’s potential 2015 salary would be a more than reasonable cost for the Cardinals.
The Cardinals do not have a dire need at catcher, but signing Hundley is a way they can get an upgrade at the position, both offensively and defensively. Molina showed signs of wear and tear in 2014, and thus the Cardinals need to bring in a better insurance option. While Hundley certainly is not the hottest name on the catching market, he would be a cheap upgrade, and the Cardinals need to take advantage of that.
Drew Jenkins is an MLB writer and Sabermetrics Columnist for www.RantSports.com. Follow him on Twitter @DrewJenkins77, “Like” him on Facebook, add him to your network on Google, or contact him at [email protected].
5 Free Agents Tampa Bay Rays Could Pursue
Who should the Tampa Bay Rays pursue during the offseason? Read More
Yankees' Top 10 Prospects For 2015
The Yankees have never been known for their strong farm system, but these 10 players make up a relatively good group of prospects. Read More
5 Free Agents San Diego Padres Could Pursue
Who should the San Diego Padres pursue during the offseason? Read More
5 Free Agents Minnesota Twins Could Pursue
Who should the Minnesota Twins pursue during the offseason? Read More
5 Free Agents Houston Astros Could Pursue
Who should the Astross pursue during the offseason? Read More
5 Free Agents Colorado Rockies Could Pursue
Who should the Colorado Rockies pursue during the offseason? Read More
Projected Contracts For Top 10 MLB Free Agents
These are the top 10 free agents that still haven't found a home. There are plenty of teams interested in all of them and this is how much it will cost to sign them. Read More
Matt Adams Should Get New Deal With Cardinals
It's time for the St. Louis Cardinals to pay Matt what he is really worth. Read More
Braves' Justin Upton Will Be Moved, But Where?
Atlanta Braves outfielder Justin Upton will have a new home in 2015, but where will he be moved? Read More
Giants Not Interested in Bidding War For Sandoval
The San Francisco Giants aren't interested in engaging the Boston Red Sox and San Diego Padres in a bidding war to retain free agent third baseman Pablo Sandoval. Read More
Top 50 MLB FA Tracker (Updated 11/22)
Updates on the latest free agent rumblings and signings. Keep checking back as more stars sign with new teams. Read More
Radhames Liz Experiment Won't Work in Pittsburgh
The Pirates have been highly successful in resurrecting pitchers' careers, but don't get excited about that happening with Liz. Read More