New York Knicks Should Give The “Big Three” Another Chance

Amar'e Stoudemire, Carmelo Anthony and Tyson Chandler on the sidelines.

Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports

Once upon a time, in 2011, the New York Knicks gutted their roster to bring in Carmelo Anthony from the Denver Nuggets to join Amar’e Stoudemire. The following season, the Knicks signed Tyson Chandler away from the Dallas Mavericks to form an imposing Big Three that could compete with the Miami Heat.

Almost three years later, the Knicks’ Big Three is laughable compared to other trios in the NBA, but they haven’t been given much of a chance lately.

The Knicks are on the outside looking in at a playoff spot this season. If they make the playoffs, they won’t get very far. So with that in mind, the Knicks need to do everything they can to position themselves for a successful offseason this summer. Increasing the value of a player such as Stoudemire, who was the first of the big three to join the Knicks, is essential for their future.

The Knicks should run out a lineup of Raymond Felton at point, Tim Hardaway Jr. at shooting guard, Anthony at small forward, Stoudemire at power forward and Chandler at center. This is what the Knicks envisioned (not necessarily Hardaway Jr. or Felton) when they got the trio to come to New York, but after it failed to work the first few times, they gave up. It’s time to give it another chance.

With that starting lineup, the Knicks could run a bench lineup of Pablo Prigioni as the main ball handler, J.R. Smith as the go-to scorer, Metta World Peace and Iman Shumpert for defense on the wings, and either Andrea Bargnani, Kenyon Martin or Jeremy Tyler down low depending on availability and matchups.

What’s the worse that could happen? The Knicks miss the playoffs? Well, that looks likely already. The best that can happen is that they find some success with it, make the playoffs, and Stoudemire looks more like the 2010 Stoudemire who had the MSG crowd going wild.

Heading into the final year of his contract, coupled with performing at a high level again, Stoudemire might be able to yield a first-round draft pick that the Knicks desperately need if they choose to trade him. But none of that can happen unless the Knicks shuffle their lineup to reflect their original plan.

Kellin Bliss is a New York Knicks writer for RantSports.com. Follow him on Twitter or “Like” him on Facebook.

Around the Web

  • http://www.febsports.com/febs/viewforum.php?f=32 Kaya

    The close the Knicks came to having a BIG-3 were (Amare, Melo, and Billups), but Melo kept begging for the ball every time on every offensive-possession messed that BIG-3 up.
    Melo wanting to control the offense so he can score on isolation plays, to pad his scoring stats by getting a touch of the ball on every offensive-possession had the Knicks interim GM Glen Grunwald Amnesty a one year contract Billups, which left the Knicks without a lead PG to start the Knicks 2011-12 season. Which got off to a 8-15 record start.
    The Knicks had to look in the D.League for a PG.
    And a Star was born in New York name “Linsanity”, who took a 8-15 record Knicks on a couple of win streak runs to get a 24-24 Knicks record without Carmelo Anthony in the lineup.
    Carmelo Anthony had interim GM Glen Grunwald get rid of Linsanity too.
    If u ever heard the line “me, myself, and I” well that’s Carmelo Anthony BIG-3 .. Selfish Ball-Hoggin to pad his stats…