16 of 16
1. AJ McCarron, Alabama Crimson Tide
Derick Hingle - US PRESSWIRE
A.J. McCarron takes the top spot in these rankings simply because he’s the perfect quarterback…for the Alabama Crimson Tide.
It is no secret how Nick Saban plans to win football games: Strong defense, productive running game, minimal mistakes. Saban doesn’t ask for a lot out of his quarterbacks, other than to avoid screwing up, which gets them labeled as “game managers” more often than not.
While “game manager” is normally a terrible insult for quarterbacks, McCarron has thrived in the role. He has led the Tide offense without ego, following the game plan to victory, no matter how limited his opportunities to throw the ball are. And they are quite limited.
On the season, McCarron has thrown for just 1,894 yards, good for 205 yards per game. That number is a bit more impressive when you look closer and see that McCarron averages just 22 pass attempts per game (good for a 9.06 yards per attempt average). What he’s been able to do with those opportunities, however, has been the most impressive.
McCarron is completing two out of every three pass attempts (66.67%) and boasts the third-best efficiency rating in all of college football (173.54). He’s thrown for 19 touchdowns on the season, with at least one touchdown pass in eight of their nine games and two or more in six of nine. Most importantly, he’s thrown zero interceptions.
He has stepped up as a leader for the Crimson Tide as they roll towards another BCS Championship game appearance, coming up big on drives when they’ve needed him most. He isn’t going to set a box score on fire with his stats, but he doesn’t need to. He’s playing his role absolutely perfectly for Saban’s unanimous No. 1 team, which makes him the No. 1 quarterback in 2012.