Close Article Return to stream X
NCAA Football

Death To The BCS, And The Demand For A Better Playoff System

Dale Zanine-USA TODAY Sports

With the seemingly counterintuitive, and geographically chaotic realignment of college conferences, it has been brought to the forefront of people’s minds how redundant the new playoff system is setting itself up to be.

Several college football heavyweights, such as ESPN personality Kirk Herbstreit, are up in arms about Northern Illinois berth into a BCS bowl game over Georgia. This is because highly qualified and higher ranked teams fell well short of a desired bowl, at the expense of the BCS’ failed non-automatic qualifying rules.

As most know, the playoff system (to begin in 2014), was approved by 11 commissioners from the 11 major conferences, and Notre Dame Athletic Director, Jack Swarbrick – who also suggested a trial playoff run to begin in 2013.

The playoff system will consist of four teams (conference champions given preference, of course), selected by a committee using strength of schedule, wins-to-losses, and other guidelines. The semifinals will rotate bowls, with the winners heading to the National Championship.

While this seems simple, to the point, and non-controversial, fans are already outraged that the NCAA is even considering adding to the playoffs down the line, instead of going all-in with at least 16 teams from the start.

It has come to my attention, and many others, that fans want a playoff system very similar to the NFL. Sure, there are complaints, and deciding who goes to the playoffs out of 32 teams, as opposed to 120 (FBS) is easier, but it’s a unified “deal with it”-type system.

This would also eliminate the need for realignments for teams wanting AQ statuses, and help get teams back onto their respective “grids”. If it makes, money, it makes sense, and as we all know, this will help sell tickets and increase revenues.

Picture a “Pacific v. Atlantic” system, where the country would be split down the middle, divided into quadrants, with even numbers of teams in each quadrant. These quadrants would be divisions, which could help create an NFL-like scenario of divisional playoffs, then conference championships much like the Super Bowl, which the NCAA is currently vetting in hopes their existing playoff system will emulate.

People are worried that the new system would wreak havoc in determining who would play in the other bowl games. A simple solution for that would be to take the similar guidelines the NCAA already has in place for deciding the semifinalists, and apply them to seeded match-ups, assigning opponents down the line. This rigid system would give next to no grey area, and teams would already know what they had to do before the season began.

When I polled this question on Twitter, similar responses were given, such as the NFL’s 16 playoff teams. A suggestion of six at-large teams, plus 10 conference champions was given, but that wouldn’t entirely eliminate the nation’s contempt for SEC dominance.

Considering the NCAA is fueled by its’ member institutions, more consideration to the requests of those institutions, and their fans should be given. With this constant shift, it’s only a matter of time before once prolific conferences either implode or burst at the seams. This has, and will continue to be suggested, so with the conference iron still hot, now is the time for institutions and fans to act, instead of leaving these decisions in the hands of the independents, and major conferences to decide.

Follow VF Castro on Twitter: @VFdoesFootball

 

Your Favorites
 
 
Close Article Return to stream X
NCAA Football Videos

Mountain West Daily (2/5/16)

Fresno State women’s tennis is playing in the ITA National Indoor Championships, Air Force football coach Troy Calhoun agrees to a contract extension and former Falcon quarterback Chris Beake heads to his second Super Bowl in three years as a defensive assistant for the Denver Broncos.

Comment 0 Comments
 
 
Close Article Return to stream X
NCAA Football Videos

Broncos WR Demaryius Thomas: Top 4 Games at Georgia Tech

Broncos WR Demaryius Thomas exploded onto the scene in 2009 for the Yellow Jackets and was a tremendous playmaker. Even GT's option-oriented offense could not conceal the weapon that was affectionately known as "Bay Bay". Thomas put together some awesome games in his time in Atlanta. Enjoy four of his greatest performances right here!

Comment 0 Comments
 
 
Close Article Return to stream X
NCAA Football Videos

Carolina Panthers LB Luke Kuechly Boston College Hype Video

Luke Kuechly's legendary career at Boston College led him to the Carolina Panthers, where he has been one of the most dominant forces in the NFL. Luke has been the catalyst for a prolific Panthers defense that will now be tested on the biggest stage of all, Super Bowl 50! Enjoy this special Super Bowl edition of the best of Luke Kuechly while a BC Eagle!

Comment 0 Comments
 
 
Close Article Return to stream X
NCAA Football Videos

SEC's Best Super Bowl Performers

Several SEC alums have been standout Super Bowl performers dating back to the game's inception in 1967. With Cam Newton and Peyton Manning headlining Super Bowl 50, take a look back at other former SEC stars that made it to the game's biggest stage.

Comment 0 Comments
 
 
Close Article Return to stream X
NCAA Football Videos

Cam Newton's Celebration Inspiration?

Panthers QB Cam Newton's celebrations have received plenty of attention during his team's path to Super Bowl 50. But what's the inspiration for the 2010 Heisman Trophy winner's moves? We take a look back to his Auburn days to help explain where his "Superman" celebration came from.

Comment 0 Comments
 
 
Close Article Return to stream X
NCAA Football Videos

Best Names From National Signing Day | The Feed

National Signing Day 2016 is in the books with the nation's top recruits choosing their schools. In this edition of "The Feed brought to you by Cici's Pizza," Shae Peppler goes through some of the best names from the Class of 2016 and how Campus Insiders chooses to think of them.

Comment 0 Comments