Troy Aikman Mistakenly Says Tony Romo is the Better Dallas Cowboys QB

Dallas Cowboys Hall of Fame quarterback Troy Aikman suffered more than his share of concussions during the twilight of his career. Apparently, those blows to the head are starting to take a toll on the best passer in Cowboys history. On Tuesday, Aikman made a crazy statement regarding current Cowboys quarterback Tony Romo.

“I think Tony already is a better quarterback than I was,” Aikman said. “I know how quarterbacks are judged but as far as his play-making ability and the things that he is capable of doing, he is a far more athletic quarterback, capable of making more plays than I ever was able to.”

Romo may have the best stats of any Dallas quarterback, but that certainly doesn’t mean he is the best quarterback in Cowboys history. Romo may have 149 touchdowns in just 77 starts compared to Aikman’s 165 scores in 165 starts, but the two are nowhere near comparable.

In his 77 starts, Romo has thrown 2,592 passes to Aikman’s 4,715 in 165 starts. Aikman averaged only 28.5 passes per start while Romo has thrown 33.6 passes per start. The difference in numbers Romo throws 17% more passes every game than Aikman did in his Hall of Fame career. The only difference that matters is the Cowboys won those games with Aikman at the helm.

Sure, Romo has more 300-yard passing games and 4,000-yard passing seasons than Aikman and fellow Cowboys Hall of Fame quarterback Roger Staubach, but Romo isn’t the player that either of those guys were. The Cowboys won because of Staubach; the guy’s nickname was “Captain Comeback” for Tom Landry’s sake. Aikman also proved his greatness by rescuing the Cowboys and coming through when his team needed him.

The main thing about Staubach and Aikman that separates them from Romo is the Cowboys never lost because of them. The Cowboys have lost on several occasions because of Romo and that’s why he’s not better than Aikman, regardless of what the modest legend says.

However, Aikman’s final comments provide an interesting segue to the next chapter in Romo’s career.

“He has a good team around him,” Aikman said. “Hopefully — and I believe this will happen — I believe that he will win a Super Bowl before he is done playing.”

Aikman had a tremendous team around him; the 1992 Cowboys are arguably the greatest team of all time. Aikman had a Hall of Fame running back in Emmitt Smith and a Hall of Fame receiver in Michael Irvin to make plays on offense and a stifling defense that ranked first in the NFL.

To this point in his career, Romo hasn’t had a running back like that and his receivers are just now hitting their stride as well. In 2012, Romo and the Cowboys have no such excuse. Romo has a workhorse running back in DeMarco Murray and a great third-down back in Felix Jones. Miles Austin and Dez Bryant are one of the top receiver tandems in the league and Jason Witten is arguably the best tight end in the game.

So what Aikman said has some truth to it. Romo is capable of being a better quarterback than Aikman, but first he’s got to fix his mistakes that cost the Cowboys valuable wins. As mentioned, Aikman never caused the Cowboys to lose in the prime of his career.

Ultimately, Romo is going to have to win some Super Bowls to be compared to Staubach and Aikman. The two of them are responsible for all five Lombardi Trophies in Dallas and that’s the way quarterbacks are measured, regardless of fairness.

Aikman’s comments may have been kind and Romo has received similar remarks from Staubach, but it’s not the truth. Romo is not a better quarterback than Aikman or Staubach and won’t be until he makes winning a habit in Dallas again.

Follow Jeric Griffin on Twitter @JericGriffin or on Facebook at Jeric Griffin – Rant Sports


Around the Web

  • Pingback: Troy Aikman Mistakenly Says Tony Romo is the Better Dallas Cowboys QB

  • Pingback: Troy Aikman Mistakenly Says Tony Romo is the Better Dallas Cowboys QB – Rant Sports | mefaba.com

  • http://jerkyloversnetwork.com Robby

    Well, I agree with most of this that he is no Aikman. Aikman is classier, was more mature and had a great coach for 5 season of his career. But here is the way I look at Romo.

    Not a drafted QB.
    Played @ Div II College
    Has not had the offensive line that the other 4 top QB’s have had in front of him or Aikman had and remember, Aikman was a 1st rounder!
    Has not had a consistent running game though there was some bright spots a few years ago.
    Did tie the franchise record of 13 and 3 and had Crayton caught one of those dropped passes in the home playoff game against NYG a few years ago, he may have ended up in the Superbowl.
    And, through the mistakes he has made that cost some games, he has been able to shrug those off and not let them get to him!
    Name me another undrafted, 3rd and 4th on the depth chart QB’s that never sees reps during the regular season, to come in after a top drafted vet who played in a superbowl threw (Drew Bledsoe) one too many pics, and has put up the numbers Romo has! You could probably count them on one hand!

    Also think about just this! Put Romo behind say the Pats offensive line and I think he out throws Brady! Just Sayin!

    • http://yardbark Slimboywane

      Well said I like it but hope it gets better.
      Slim

  • Yuran Idiot

    Of course he made mistakes that contributed to the Boys losing games.Every HOF QB has had off-days even in his prime.I recall key INTs against the Niners, a fumble in the endzone at RFK, passing into coverage and getting the WR blown up, causing a turnover.
    When a QB feels he has to do everything because his teammates aren’t pulling their own weight, he’s going to over-extend. Romo has been far too often battling alone out there. OL missing blocks, WRs running incorrect routes, false starts that kill momentum, holding penalties that put us in a hole…

    He’s an athlete, he’s got skills, he’s doing his job. STFU and listen to someone who knows FAR more than you on the subject; HOF QB Troy Aikman.

  • Pingback: troy aikman

  • Pingback: troy aikman | A FACE IN A BOOK

  • Pingback: troy aikman

  • Pingback: troy aikman | A FACE IN A BOOK

  • Pingback: troy aikman

  • Pingback: troy aikman | A FACE IN A BOOK

  • Pingback: troy aikman | A FACE IN A BOOK

  • Pingback: troy aikman

  • Pingback: troy aikman | A FACE IN A BOOK

  • Pingback: troy aikman

  • Pingback: troy aikman | A FACE IN A BOOK

  • Pingback: troy aikman | A FACE IN A BOOK

  • Pingback: troy aikman

  • Pingback: troy aikman | A FACE IN A BOOK

  • Pingback: troy aikman

  • Pingback: best gift for mom