10 NHL Players: Put Away the Skates and Retire

1 of 11

10 NHL Players Who Need To Hang 'Em Up

Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports

The NHL can be considered an old man's club at times. There are certain players that tend to stay longer than they should. This happens in every sport. It was weird to watch a 40-year-old Brett Favre put on a Minnesota Vikings jersey just to stay around for a few more seasons. Seeing Michael Jordan put on a Washington Wizards jersey is something most basketball fans are trying to forget. You can even go back to Willie Mays giving up the black and orange to wear blue and orange. He was with the New York Mets at the end of his career. Sometimes the competitive nature of an athlete makes him look silly towards the end.

Hockey seems to be the sport that does this most often. Players continually play into their 40's, even though their skills have eroded to a point that they are just role players. You see players like Gordie Howe who played into his 50's. Something like that seems impossible today. You saw it recently with Chris Chelios playing in the Atlanta Thrashers minor leagues just to try to get one more shot at 46 years old.

There are plenty of older players in the league. The two oldest skaters, Jaromir Jagr and Teemu Selanne, surprisingly did not make the list. They both showed over the past two seasons that they can still play at a high level. The players on this list are either hanging on for a cheap Stanley Cup, trying to make a couple extra bucks or just don't have anything else to scratch that "itch". These ten players may still have something left, but sometimes it just isn't worth it to see them play at anything less than their top level.

2 of 11

Martin Brodeur

Ed Mulholland-USA TODAY Sports

Martin Brodeur has shown signs of the greatness that made him statistically the greatest goaltender of all time, but he continues to get hurt. At one point in his career it seemed like the guy never even missed a week with injuries. Now, he seems to have a minor back injury and miss a month. On top of that, he doesn't play up to his former standards when he does return. With Cory Schneider in the fold, Brodeur should know what is best for the New Jersey Devils. Now, they have to go into the season with a 41-year-old starter and it is only a matter of time before he has to be in the trainer's room for a few weeks, if not months.

3 of 11

Todd Bertuzzi

Red Wings
Rick Osentoski-USA TODAY Sports

Todd Bertuzzi should have retired when he ended the career of Steve Moore. A promising 25-year-old, he never got to get back on the ice after the incident where Bertuzzi broke three vertebrae in Moore's neck. Beyond that, he just doesn't have the ability anymore. He only played seven games last season with a variety of ailments. He is currently playing for a job that is not guaranteed on the Detroit Red Wings. The team has enough age and have no need for Bertuzzi. He needs to put his skates up and end a career that was riddled with controversy. He needs to try and handle all the lawsuits against him anyway.

4 of 11

Ryan Smyth

Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports

Ryan Smyth seems to have aged faster than any hockey player. He is coming back to the Edmonton Oilers to most likely be a fourth-line player. He scored a whopping two goals in the lockout-shortened season, even though he played all but one game. His powerplay game, the same game that put him into stardom in the first place, is no longer there.

At 37 years old, Smyth just isn't the player that got all those goals in the early 2000's for this Oilers team. If he wants to stay with the team and mentor the young players, I am sure they could find some kind of coaching position for him, but he just isn't that much of a contributor on the ice. He is still decent on the penalty kill, but teams can get that for much cheaper than, $2.25 million per season. It is time for Smyth to say goodbye to Edmonton once again.

5 of 11

Nikolai Khabibulin

Anne-Marie Sorvin-USA TODAY Sports

Nikolai Khabibulin has been a very good backup the past couple of seasons. The problem is, if he is called upon to play more games than he is used to his stats go down considerably. You saw last season with Johan Hedberg on the Devils. When Brodeur went down with injury, fans thought they were in good shape with Hedberg. He was absolutely awful. Khabibulin isn't that bad, but will he be okay at his advanced age?

The Chicago Blackhawks are taking a chance using the "Bulin Wall" to replace Ray Emery, who was no short of spectacular last season. The team needs a guy they can count on in case something happens to Corey Crawford, and Khabibulin is not that guy.

6 of 11

Milan Hejduk

Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports

Milan Hejduk may actually play a season outside of the Colorado Avalanche for the first time in his career. He has spent all of his 14 seasons with the same franchise, but now that franchise feels it could get similar contributions elsewhere. Hejduk is still a free agent and has shown no expectation to retire. It is sad when you see situations like this: when a guy just doesn't want to give up the game he loves, but there aren't any teams who want him. Hejduk should try to keep some of his pride and go out after a season where he couldn't contribute like he has before. It is time for him to say goodbye to the game, just like the Avalanche did to him.

7 of 11

Evgeni Nabokov

Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports

This one sounds crazy. Nabokov took a New York Islanders team all the way to the playoffs. On top of that, he almost helped upset the top seeded Pittsburgh Penguins. The team seemed to bring him back reluctantly after Ray Emery decided it would be better to go to the Philadelphia Flyers.

He has decent stats (.910 save percentage, 2.50 goals against average), but his defense will get worse with the loss of Mark Streit. He was probably the reason the Islanders didn't have a chance in the playoffs with his .842 save percentage. He just isn't as consistent as he once was. He is a below-average player at a time when he can't make much of a difference.

8 of 11

Jamie Langenbrunner

Scott Rovak-USA TODAY Sports

Jamie Langenbrunner has gone from a guy who was captain of the USA hockey team, to a guy who can't even find a job in hockey from the span of Vancouver to Sochi. He has not been nearly as effective since being traded by the Devils back in 2011. He is unable to get more than 20 points anymore, and lately it has been closer to ten. He had one point in four NHL games last season. He fought a torn labium in his hip. When you start having hip problems you are just never the same, just ask Alex Rodriguez. It is time for Langenbrunner to stop.

9 of 11

Ray Whitney

Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports

Ray Whitney made his mistake signing with the Dallas Stars. He is playing for a team that isn't going anywhere. He is one of two productive players, the other being Jamie Benn. The team traded away Michael Ryder, Derek Roy and Jagr within the season to completely bottom out. Whitney should have tried to be one of those players who was sent out. He is going to waste what is most likely his last season on a team that is just that, a waste. Unless he gets a trade, he should start working on the golf game and enjoy retirement. It just isn't worth it, even if he does like the new jerseys.

10 of 11

Jose Theodore

Robert Mayer-USA TODAY Sports

Jose Theodore has had an interesting career. He has played with five franchises since he left the Montreal Canadiens in 2006. He is about to add a sixth. There are rumors he will be going to play for the Boston Bruins. They are trying to get a backup on the cheap. Theodore wasn't even good enough to be a backup last season. He posted a .893 save percentage and a 3.29 GAA. Those are not good enough to be an NHL goalie today. That seems like a loss every time Tuuka Rask needs a day off. Theodore needs to know when to fold his hand, and it is time to fold this chapter of his career.

11 of 11

Daniel Alfredsson

Red Wings
Bob DeChiara-USA TODAY Sports

Don't get me wrong, Daniel Alfredsson is still very, very good. He may have struggled last season and his age may be catching up with him, but he is still a contributing NHL player. The reason he needs to put away the skates is he IS the Ottawa Senators. More than any player epitomizes their team, he was the Senators; He was more than Brodeur for the Devils, Alex Ovechkin for the Washington Capitals, or Sidney Crosby with the Penguins.

Alfredsson was a Senator, and then he was a great player. Now he is a Red Wing. Nothing makes sense anymore when a guy like that would move within the division (although it is a new division, but still) to try and win a cup without the team he has been associated with for the past 17 years; I would rather see him retire.

Around the Web

  • BMRking

    Farve didn’t just stay around, he was still productive. I’d still take him over half these jokers

  • Jon

    Most of these players still contribute at a high level in the NHL. You obviously don’t know much about hockey.

    • Robert Mango

      He said the Isles d will get worse without Mark Streit. I think that removes all validity from the article.

      • I love Phishstyx

        It was the right move letting Mark Striet go……Now it obvious

  • Mark T

    Don’t forget Iggy

  • Mark H

    Moore was not a promising 25 year old. He was a plug

  • bobringer

    Yeah… Brodeur constantly misses a month at a time?

    You checked your facts, right? You can go back to 2008 for an actual example of an extended injury… which proves that in 2003/2004 that he’s too old. His 2.22 GAA last year is further proof that he’s too old, right? #8 GAA for goalies that played as many or more games than him. This guy is clearly a joke in goal.


    • Nick Villano

      Problem is that an injury that would take a week to recover for a 30 year old takes him a month and his save percentage was near the bottom of the league. I personally love Brodeur and say he could start on half of the league’s teams, but does he want to be a middle of the pack goalie or would he rather retire while still at some sort of peak?

  • Grumpy Old Coach

    Tyler Seguin may be a drunk, but that kid can play….. pretty sure he’s the most productive player in Dallas right now….

  • J Paul Read

    How is Brad Richards not on this list?

    • joeydefiant

      scored twice last nite…

  • MarthasVineyard14

    Jaromir Jagr still contributing at a high level? Winded after 20 seconds, and the hands are GONES-VILLE. It’s over.

  • Daniel

    lost all credibility when you said the isles defense will get worse without Mark Streit. did you see his +- from last season?

  • Shemp

    add Matt Cooke…before he kills somebody!

  • tevra

    I agree this guy doesn’t know his hockey….he just wanted to make an article.
    Next time write about tea parties and My Little Pony – For damn sure you know more about them than you do about a man’s sport

  • ru12xu

    To say that Nabolov will be hurt by the loss of Streit truly demonstrates that you have no clue