Pittsburgh Pirates Need To Find Platoon Partner For Neil Walker
The Pittsburgh Pirates have themselves a very good second baseman in Neil Walker. I seem to write a lot of negative posts about Walker, but I really don’t think he’s a bad player. I just think the Pirates are putting him, and the team, in a bad position by continuing to let him hit against left-handed pitching.
Against right-handed pitchers, Walker is an above-average offensive second baseman with a .277/.393/.463 slash line in 211 plate appearances in 2013. His walk rate is at 11.4 percent when he is batting left-handed, compared to just a 7.4 percent from the right side of the plate.
When hitting right-handed in 2013 — against left-handed pitching, obviously – Walker is hitting for an awful .170/.231/.170 slash line. Granted, it’s a small sample size — only 54 plate appearances – but it is still really ugly to look at.
I have a hard time believing the Pirates will look to replace him as the full-time second baseman because he’s obviously a valuable player to the Pirates and is a “hometown hero” who has a ton of fans. However, I do think Pirates general manager Neal Huntington needs to search hard on the trade market for a second baseman or utility infielder that can hit southpaws.
My biggest fear in a potential wild card play-in game for the Pirates is that if the opposing team starts a tough left-handed pitcher, the Pirates wouldn’t stand a chance. Walker can’t hit lefties, and Pedro Alvarez, Garrett Jones and Travis Snider also struggle against southpaws.
While looking through the potential available second baseman, I found two players in particular who shouldn’t cost a ton and could handle lefties fairly well.
First, Nick Punto. He can play shortstop, second base and third base. His UZR/150 at shortstop is 6.9, 5.2 at second base and 25.5 at third base. Obviously, his best defensive position is third base, but Alvarez is becoming a much better hitter and a platoon with the third baseman isn’t entirely necessary.
Against southpaws in 2013, Punto is hitting for a .328/.391/.379 slash line. He’s not going to provide power, but he will certainly erase the black hole the Pirates have at second base against left-handed pitching, and he will provide great defense when he gets playing time.
The second guy I found is Darwin Barney. He won’t be a utility guy like Punto, as he is a pure second baseman. He plays very good defense at second base too, with a 12.1 UZR/150. Against southpaws, Barney has a .292/.370/.492 slash line. He will likely be harder to acquire than Punto, however.
Both players would be great fits with the Pirates, and I think one of them needs to be a Pirate by Aug. 1.
Ranking Astros' Top 10 Prospects Heading Into 2015
The Astros have one of the best farm systems in baseball and could be much better soon. These 10 players are part of the next wave of talent. Read More